French court fines 7 people for anti-Semitic abuse against Miss France finalist
PARIS – A French court on Wednesday fined seven people for a torrent of anti-Semitic abuse on social media targeting the finalist in the latest Miss France pageant.
April Benayoum, who competed for the title of Miss France in December, was the subject of hate messages after she said at the event that her father was of Israeli descent.
The slurs – such as “Hitler forgot this one” and “Don’t vote for a Jew” – were posted mainly on Twitter and were condemned by politicians and associations.
On Wednesday, a Paris court sentenced seven defendants, four women and three men, to each pay fines ranging from 300 to 800 euros (350 to 930 dollars).
An eighth suspect was acquitted as the court concluded his tweet was not aimed directly at Benayoum.
During the trial, the suspects all admitted to posting the messages, but denied they were anti-Semitic, with some claiming they were making a political statement defending the Palestinian cause.
But the court ruled that the messages expressed “a rejection of a person because of his origins” or “because of his alleged religion” and that they were aimed directly at Benayum.
The seven were also ordered to pay one euro in damages to the candidate and to several associations against racism and anti-Semitism which had joined the plaintiffs.
Four of them were also invited to attend a two-day civic education class without, according to the court, fully grasping the gravity of their actions.
While qualifying the sanctions as “light”, Jean-Louis Lagarde, lawyer for the anti-racism association MRAP, considered that they were still “educational”.
The judgment showed that “you cannot hide behind the Internet or behind Twitter,” he said.
Benayoum’s lawyer Jean Veil said he blamed Twitter himself because the messaging platform allowed offensive tweets to remain visible for several days.
“My client thinks Twitter’s negligence is to blame in this case,” Veil said, adding that a separate case has been brought against the platform.